What better way to come back to regular writing than an
awesome Grammar Nazi blog. Let’s get right to it. Let’s set the scene for any
of the readers who don’t work, or have never worked in the ‘IT Services’
sector. A typical day, you’re sitting there, minding your own business while
staring at lines of code that represent the configuration of a server somewhere
in the world. Your overly enthusiastic colleague is doing something similar. It
turns out that some ‘business biggie’ somewhere isn't receiving emails on his
blackberry (oooh….aaah….for he’s a blackberry boy). The colleague isn’t able to
figure out what’s wrong. They turn to you and say, “The customer has an issue.
He’s unable to receive emails on his blackberry.”
You, being the smug Grammar Nazi turn to colleague with a
bewildered expression and say,” What’s the fella got against emails or blackberry?
Is it a religious thing? We’re not here to fan the fires of some person’s
personal beliefs. Maybe he should talk to the local padre.” Colleague continues
to stare at you as though you just spoke to them in German (Nazi…German….get
it?) and says, “Dude, the customer has an issue. He is not receiving emails on
his blackberry.” Sarcasm fails you the second time. That is when you realize
that years and years of bad English education, which includes the very first
Indian in the IT Services sector confusing the words ‘problem’ and ‘issue’, has
resulted in a generation of people who don’t get my sarcasm. Tsk…tsk…. What am
I to do?
Still don’t get it? Alright. Here goes. (Clears throat).
According to the English language, the one and only English language (American
English is NOT English….and ‘I am an Indian daaaa’ is also not an acceptable
excuse for talking like an idiot if you do it with an American accent), the
words ‘issue’ and ‘problem’ hold two very distinct meanings.
Let’s take some real world examples; ‘rash-driving’ on the
streets is a problem. How can it be solved? By ensuring that people are of the
appropriate age to drive, and once they reach that age, impose several
punishments for rash driving. That is a problem. However, is 18 the right age
to be allowed to drive, or is 21 the right age to be allowed to drive? Now that
is an issue. There is no right or wrong. Some people feel that if someone is 18
years of age, they possess the adequate civil sense to drive responsibly, while
others feel 21 would be a more apt age to hand someone a driving license. While
both remain equally valid points of view, by consensus we choose 18 to be the
legal age to drive a motor vehicle. But we all agree that anyone driving in a
rash manner should be punished. We have a solution to the problem, although not
a permanent one.
Hence, going by the example,
Problem – An unpleasant situation to which corrective action
that can be taken hence is mitigating the unpleasant situation. The solution is
not open to debate. There may be more than one way to solve a problem, some
better than others, but it is still solvable.
Issue – An unpleasant situation to which there is no one solution
and the topic at hand is open to debate. Issues normally arise from different
points of view about something, with both views having their own pros and cons.
There may be corrective measures to help solve the same, but those measures are
generally temporary and are open to debate.
So if the darn customer can’t receive an email on his
blackberry, that’s a problem. It is not open to debate. Some software or
hardware is not working properly and needs to be fixed. And it can be fixed. That
makes this a problem. We are not going to debate if that person should be
allowed to read email on his blackberry or not? There is no issue. Should
people read email in general? Should Blackberry be a proper device upon which
to read email? These are topics we could discuss over a long coffee.
I remember the first time when we were told that we would be
solving customer issues, I thought I’d spend hours of time on the phone
consoling people like I were some sort of a Shrink. Then I figured they meant
problems. On one such occasion, one of the fellow engineers told a customer in
the UK to call him if he had any issues. The customer politely told him that
his personal issues were his own and that the engineer should just ensure that
IT infrastructure was up and running. The engineer thanked the customer and cut
the call blissfully unaware of what just happened. Yours truly on the other
hand was laughing his head off….. And no wonder they think I’m a little off my
rocker.
What annoys me is that this is a ‘problem’ and it can be
solved. The ‘issue’ lies in telling someone that 12 odd years of schooling was
wrong and they’ve got to learn to say the right thing. The worst part of all
this ‘issue-problem’ business is that even graduates from premier business
schools joining the IT services sector make the same mistake. And these are
chaps who aced the ‘English-knowledge’ section in their entrance exams.
My fellow engineers, we are here to solve problems like ‘Internet
not working’, ‘email not accessible’. We are not here to help customers with
questions like ‘Are gay-marriages alright?’, ‘should I hand my 12 year old his
first bottle of scotch?’…the latter are issues. Our awesome degrees do not
permit us to be judges on the same. So for heaven’s sake, please stop saying
that ‘The customers have issues and we solve them’. We’re the ones who have
issues with such deplorable English.
PS: The author of this blog is not sitting on a high horse
nor has he had any personal relationship with either Wren or Martin. He’s just
a concerned fellow Indian who feels that it is his place to help correct such
basic problems. If you have an issue with him, please do not write to him for
he shall blog about it.
PPS: I know some of you will now hunt for grammatical errors in my post and then ask me not to correct people's English when my English isn't that great.....to you I say "Whatevaaaaaaaaaaaaa"!
Comments
@Ranga - Aei, go man. Don't pull this counter-MBA naaaansense on me!